CICA Compensation Delays: Why One Victim’s Two-Year Wait Is Sadly Familiar

Last Updated: 4 November 2026 I Reading Time: 5 minutes I By Steven Astley, Managing Partner and Head of Injury at GLP Solicitors

A recent article published by MoneySavingExpert highlights the difficulties victims of violent crime can face when seeking compensation through the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA).

Haris Armstrong describes an unprovoked assault which left him with a fractured jaw and damaged teeth. Having applied for compensation in December 2024, he was still awaiting a decision almost two years later. His account describes difficulties obtaining medical evidence, understanding requests and getting answers, while fairly acknowledging that some delays arose on his side.

Sadly, the experience he describes is familiar to our specialist team.

At GLP Solicitors, we are one of the firms at the forefront of criminal injury compensation expertise and lobbying for improvements to the system. Our work combines representing victims in complex claims with pressing for changes informed by the difficulties we encounter in practice.

In more than 25 years of representing victims of violent crime, I have seen how seeking compensation can become another demanding chapter in an already difficult experience. Victims may be recovering from serious injuries, navigating a criminal investigation and trying to rebuild their lives. A prolonged compensation process adds further uncertainty.

CICA compensation delays: the figures show a wider problem

CICA’s own annual report for 2025/26 demonstrates the pressure on the system:

  • 47,402 new applications were received, while 35,944 cases were resolved.
  • The live caseload increased by 19% to 65,638.
  • 62% of applicants received a first decision within 12 months, against a target of 70%.
  • Just over half of the live 2012 Scheme caseload had been open for at least a year, including cases at review or appeal.

These figures measure different stages of the process. An older live case may already have received an initial decision. Nevertheless, they demonstrate that lengthy waits affect a substantial number of applicants.

Behind each outstanding application is a person waiting to understand whether they will receive compensation and what that might mean for their future.

Why do CICA compensation claims take so long?

I have no desire to make excuses for CICA about delays in the system, but understanding the reasons for delay can help alleviate some of the frustrations people encounter.

Some claims need time to be assessed properly.

CICA may require police information (a process that alone can take over a year), medical records or specialist evidence about the lasting effects of an injury. Where treatment is continuing, it may be too early to establish the long-term prognosis. CICA recognises that complex cases can take longer for these reasons.

An accurate assessment matters. A claim concluded prematurely may fail to reflect the full consequences of an injury, particularly where there are lasting psychological effects, an inability to work or significant future needs.

However, applicants should understand why they are waiting. They should know what evidence is outstanding, who is responsible for obtaining it and what needs to happen next.

Necessary investigation should be accompanied by clear explanations and active case management. Prolonged uncertainty should never become an accepted feature of the process simply because it is common.

How does poor communication affect CICA applicants?

For many victims, the difficulty is the combination of delay and uncertainty.

Has the medical evidence arrived? Is anything else needed? Has a deadline been missed? Is someone actively considering the application?

Without clear answers, applicants can be left worrying that they have done something wrong or that their claim has been forgotten. Reduced call-handling hours and a refusal to engage in routine updates have recently added to that worry.

CICA’s annual report acknowledges these problems. Stage-one complaints rose from 2,371 to 4,271 in 2025/26. Its chief executive also accepted that reducing contact-centre hours had been the wrong decision and reported steps to increase capacity.

That acknowledgement is welcome. The measure of improvement must be the experience of the people using the service.

Someone coping with trauma may struggle to make repeated telephone calls, interpret formal correspondence or chase medical records. A compensation system designed for victims must account for those difficulties in its everyday processes.

Specialist CICA claims expertise and a voice for change

At GLP Solicitors, our commitment to victims extends beyond the individual claims we handle.

We have extensive experience of CICA applications, reviews and appeals, including cases involving serious and life-changing injuries. That work gives us a close understanding of both the Scheme’s rules and the practical barriers applicants encounter.

We also contribute to efforts to improve the system. Our Neil Sugarman is involved in the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers’ working group engaging directly with CICA about its processes.

Through that work, we help bring the experience of victims and their representatives into discussions about how claims are handled. We believe specialist firms have a responsibility to use their knowledge to press for clearer communication, more effective processes and fair treatment.

Our position is straightforward: a compensation scheme for victims of violent crime should be accessible to the people it exists to serve.

What can you do if your CICA compensation claim is delayed?

Establishing what is preventing progress is often the most useful starting point.

Keep copies of correspondence and evidence, record when documents were sent and check response deadlines carefully. If a request is unclear, seek clarification promptly. If obtaining evidence is proving difficult, explain the problem before the deadline expires.

Where a claim appears to have stalled, ask what remains outstanding and what action is being taken. A service complaint may be appropriate where there has been unexplained inactivity or poor communication.

In suitable circumstances, an interim payment may be possible while the long-term effects of an injury are being established. This is not an automatic entitlement simply because an application has taken a long time.

Helping victims move forward

Applicants can apply directly to CICA without a solicitor. Specialist legal advice can, however, be particularly valuable where eligibility is disputed, injuries are serious, evidence is complex or a decision needs to be challenged.

No solicitor can guarantee a quicker decision or a successful outcome. Our role is to identify the issues, present the evidence properly, pursue progress and challenge decisions where appropriate, while keeping clients informed.

The MoneySavingExpert article gives a public voice to difficulties many applicants experience privately. It deserves attention.

Victims should be able to expect a properly considered decision within a reasonable time, an explanation when that is not possible and a process that treats them with understanding and respect.

At GLP Solicitors, we work to secure the compensation our clients are entitled to while pressing for a system that serves victims better. If you need advice about a CICA application, a delayed claim or a disputed decision, contact our specialist team.


Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my CICA compensation claim taking so long?

CICA claims can be delayed because of outstanding police information, medical records, specialist reports or evidence about the long-term effects of an injury. Complex cases may take longer to assess. However, applicants should be kept informed about outstanding evidence and the progress of their application.

How long does a CICA compensation claim take?

There is no fixed timeframe for every CICA application. Some claims can be resolved relatively quickly, while complex cases involving serious injuries, ongoing treatment or additional evidence can take considerably longer. CICA aims to make a first decision within 12 months, but its 2025/26 annual report shows that only 62% of applicants received one within this period.

Can I complain about delays in my CICA claim?

Yes. If your application has experienced unexplained delays, poor communication or a lack of progress, you can raise a complaint with CICA. Keep records of correspondence, requests for information and any responses received.

Can I receive an interim payment while waiting for CICA compensation?

In certain circumstances, CICA may make an interim payment before reaching a final decision. This may be possible where eligibility has been established but further evidence is needed to assess the full extent of an injury. Interim payments are not automatic and depend on the circumstances of the claim.

Do I need a solicitor to make a CICA claim?

No. You can apply directly to CICA without using a solicitor. However, specialist legal advice may be helpful if your claim involves serious injuries, complex medical evidence, disputed eligibility, a review or an appeal.

Can a solicitor help if my CICA claim has been refused?

Yes. A specialist solicitor can review the reasons for refusal, assess whether the decision can be challenged and advise on the relevant review or appeal process. The available options will depend on the circumstances and applicable deadlines.

Can I claim CICA compensation without a criminal conviction?

Yes. A criminal conviction is not required to apply for CICA compensation. However, applicants must meet the Scheme’s eligibility requirements, including relevant requirements concerning reporting the incident to the police and cooperating with the authorities.

Can GLP Solicitors help with delayed CICA claims?

Yes. GLP Solicitors has extensive experience in criminal injury compensation applications, reviews and appeals. Our specialist team can advise on delayed applications, evidence requirements and challenging decisions where appropriate.

If you have experienced a delay with your CICA application, are struggling to obtain compensation or disagree with a decision, GLP Solicitors may be able to help.

Contact our specialist team to discuss your circumstances and find out how we can assist with your CICA claim.

GLP Solicitors Office details

Bury Office
Telephone: 0800 111 6370
Email: bury@glplaw.com