Shaken baby syndrome: six years in prison, a lifetime of disability; has justice failed this child twice?
Last Updated: 2 November 2026 I Reading Time: 5 minutes I By Steven Astley, Managing Partner and Head of Injury at GLP Solicitors
In more than 25 years of representing victims of violent crime, I have heard time and again that people feel let down by the criminal justice system.
For many, the crime itself is only the beginning. Investigations, uncertainty, delays and the prospect of reliving their experiences in court can make an already traumatic experience even harder. Others struggle to reconcile the sentence imposed with the suffering they will carry for the rest of their lives.
Criminal proceedings must be fair, and sentencing involves more than measuring the harm caused. But understanding those principles does not necessarily make the outcome easier to accept.
There can be an enormous difference between justice being delivered and justice being felt.
A recent case involving a father who inflicted catastrophic injuries on his baby son brings that distinction into sharp focus. It also raises a question about another part of our justice system: the financial provision available to children whose lives have been permanently changed by violence.
Six years in prison for a lifetime of disability
On 29 October 2026, the Court of Appeal increased Christopher Yates’s prison sentence from four years to six years after he violently shook his six-month-old son.
According to reporting of the hearing, the child suffered severe brain injury and blindness, and is unlikely ever to learn to walk.
Yates had consumed alcohol and cocaine before the assault. The court heard that he repeatedly shook his son with force comparable to that experienced in a high-speed road traffic accident, then waited more than six hours before seeking medical assistance.
The Solicitor General referred the original sentence to the Court of Appeal. Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr concluded that it was “not only lenient but unduly so”.
The increase was an important recognition of the seriousness of the offence. Nevertheless, I understand why many people might still regard six years as profoundly inadequate.
This child may require extensive care and support throughout his life. His father has received a six-year prison sentence.
The offender’s imprisonment will come to an end. The child’s disability will not.
A prison sentence cannot reverse an injury, and its length cannot simply be matched to the duration of a victim’s suffering. But the contrast helps explain why victims and their families sometimes find the language of justice difficult to reconcile with their own experience.
There is another contrast, however, which deserves just as much attention. It concerns the compensation available to help provide for an injured child’s future.
Why should the cause of an injury make such a difference to compensation?
Imagine that a child sustained similarly catastrophic injuries in a road traffic accident caused by a negligent driver.
A successful civil claim could potentially secure damages worth millions of pounds. In a case reported in June 2026, a girl who suffered a severe brain injury in a road traffic accident received a settlement valued at approximately £22.75 million.
That case is not a valuation of this little boy’s claim. Every assessment depends on the individual evidence. It does, however, illustrate the scale of provision that may be required following a devastating childhood injury.
Such awards are not windfalls. They reflect the costs of care, specialist equipment, adapted accommodation and other losses and needs arising over a lifetime.
But what happens when a child’s injuries have been deliberately inflicted by a parent?
A civil claim against the offender may be possible in principle. In practice, there may be no insurance to meet it and no realistic prospect of recovering substantial damages from the offender personally. Whether any other civil claim is available requires separate investigation.
A child’s need for care does not become smaller because their injuries were inflicted deliberately. Yet the compensation they can realistically recover may be dramatically different.
The reporting does not establish what compensation claims have been investigated on this child’s behalf. My concern is the position a child with injuries of this severity may face where there is no realistic route to recovering civil damages.
What can the CICA pay for a catastrophic brain injury?
The Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority, or CICA, administers a government-funded scheme for victims of violent crime in England, Scotland and Wales. Children injured through violent shaking or other abuse may qualify, subject to the Scheme’s requirements.
Under the current Scheme, the maximum injury payment for the most serious brain injuries is £250,000. Even where additional qualifying payments are available, the maximum overall award is £500,000.
Those figures are ceilings, not automatic entitlements.
Compare that with the potentially multimillion-pound damages available through a successful civil claim involving catastrophic injuries.
The difference is substantial.
The CICA Scheme was never intended to reproduce full civil damages. It is a publicly funded scheme operating within prescribed rules and financial limits. That explains why the systems produce different outcomes.
It does not resolve the question of whether those outcomes are fair.
That £500,000 ceiling has remained unchanged since 1996, 30 years without an increase.
Over that time, inflation has substantially eroded its purchasing power. An award intended to help provide for a catastrophically injured child must now stretch much further.
The question is therefore not simply whether the limit was adequate when it was introduced. It is how a ceiling fixed three decades ago can be justified for children facing a lifetime of needs today.
Why should a child catastrophically injured through deliberate violence potentially receive a fraction of the compensation available to meet comparable needs arising from negligence?
From the child’s perspective, the need for support remains. Care does not cost less because an injury was caused by an assault. Specialist equipment does not become cheaper because the person responsible was a parent.
This is why I believe the debate should extend beyond the adequacy of the prison sentence. We should also ask whether the financial provision available to the most seriously injured victims of violent crime bears a reasonable relationship to the needs they face.
Why pursuing CICA compensation still matters
Criticising the limits of the Scheme should never obscure the importance of the support it can provide.
For a child who might otherwise have no realistic means of obtaining compensation, a substantial CICA award can make a meaningful difference. Its limitations make it particularly important that the child’s entitlement is properly investigated and supported.
A claim involving a seriously injured baby requires careful attention to the medical evidence and long-term prognosis. The initial diagnosis may not fully explain how the injury will affect development, independence and future care needs.
Starting an application promptly and ensuring that the final assessment adequately reflects the evidence are separate considerations. Both matter.
It is also essential that someone takes responsibility for considering the claim.
A child injured by a parent may subsequently live with relatives, foster carers or under arrangements involving a local authority. Their immediate safety and welfare rightly come first. But their potential entitlement to compensation must not disappear between the different people and organisations involved in their care.
A criminal conviction is not essential for a CICA claim, and those responsible for a child should not assume that they must wait for criminal proceedings to finish before seeking advice.
Our guide to shaken baby syndrome and abusive head trauma compensation claims explains more about eligibility, applications on behalf of children and the importance of early advice.
Helping children now, and asking whether the system should do more
There are two responsibilities here: to help injured children secure the compensation available under the present rules, and to challenge whether those rules provide adequately for the most serious injuries.
We should not have to choose between doing the best we can within the system and arguing that the system should be better.
Over my years representing victims of violent crime, I have seen how serious injuries change lives. I have also seen how difficult it can be for victims and their families to navigate processes over which they feel they have little control.
Specialist representation means listening, understanding the consequences of an injury and ensuring that the evidence properly supports the compensation being sought.
At GLP Solicitors, we help victims of serious violence, including children with life-changing injuries, pursue the compensation to which they are entitled.
No award can reverse this little boy’s brain injury or restore the childhood he should have enjoyed. Financial support can, however, help provide for his future.
A six-year sentence for the offender. A lifetime of disability for the child. And a compensation scheme whose maximum award may fall far short of the cost of lifelong care.
For me, that raises questions about justice which deserve to be asked.
While we press those questions, we must also ensure that children injured through violent crime receive the compensation to which they are entitled.
For advice about a child’s potential claim, contact GLP Solicitors on 0800 138 6061 or visit shakenbabies.co.uk.
